Contact

Greenbar vs SPS Commerce

SPS Commerce is the biggest name in this business, with more than 46,000 paying customers and hundreds of partner companies. We are not pretending to be an alternative to all of that. We are an alternative for one specific person: a small supplier with a handful of retailers who has been quoted more than the account is worth.

—Where SPS Commerce is the better choice

The network is real and we do not have one. Many retailers already have an SPS connection, with the relationship and the certification history that goes with it. If your retailer's EDI team names SPS as their preferred route, that is a genuine shortcut and it may be worth the price on its own.

Scale buys proof. 46,000 customers, named retail testimonials and a commissioned ROI study. We have an argument and a validator you can run. Those are not the same thing and it would be insulting to pretend otherwise.

They can take on what we have ruled out. Freight, healthcare, analytics, a hundred retailers at once, an ERP integration with a name you recognise. We deliberately do none of that.

Nobody gets fired for choosing the biggest name. If that matters in your business, it is a real consideration and not a joke.

—Where we are the better choice

The bill does not move with your volume. Most EDI is billed per per thousand characters of the file, and a grocery ship notice with its cartons and part numbers runs about ten of them. At 3¢ to 30¢ each that is a charge on every document, every month, and it is why a monthly figure on a quote tells you so little. Our founding plan does not count documents, and the standard plan caps the subscription at $199.

Grocery is built, not adapted. Grocery runs on its own transaction sets — an 875 instead of an 850, an 880 instead of an 810 — and they are not renamed versions of the general sets. We built both pairs against each retailer's own published implementation guide: Kroger, Albertsons, UNFI, KeHE, H-E-B, Publix, Wakefern, Meijer and the rest.

You can check our work before you talk to us. The validator runs in your browser and uploads nothing, and all 219 errors the software can produce are published with what each one means. Neither needs a call, a form or a trial.

The price is on the page. Not a range, not "starting at", not a request for a conversation. It is right here.

—What each one costs

SPS Commerce: no pricing is published on their site. The figure comes from a conversation with a salesperson, scoped to your partners and volume.

We are not going to invent a number for them, and you should be wary of any comparison page that does. What we will say is what to ask for in writing before you sign anything: the per-kilocharacter or per-document rate, the setup fee per trading partner, what happens to the price when you add the fourth retailer, and the length of the term. Those four answers are the whole cost, and the monthly figure is usually the smallest of them.

Greenbar: $79 a month, or $69 for the first ten accounts. One-off $199 setup on the standard plan, none on the founding rate. Additional retailers $39, or $29 founding. On the standard plan one retailer and 500 documents a month are included and it is 6¢ a document after that; on the founding plan documents are not metered at all. The subscription stops climbing at $199, or $149 founding. Billing begins when your first production document arrives, not at signup.

Ours is on the pricing section of the home page and in the FAQ, in full, including the parts that cost you more.

—Moving across, if you decide to

Nothing has to be switched off while you decide. Your retailer can send to both of us at once, because we take delivery on our own SFTP rather than needing a change at their end — so you run in parallel until your retailer has certified us, and then you cancel the other one. If something is wrong in ours, the live connection is still the old one.

What we need from you is the retailer's name. We read their implementation guide ourselves; we do not ask you to export a mapping or explain their qualifiers. If your current vendor will give you their mapping, it is useful, and if they will not, it changes nothing.

And if you leave us: everything exports in CSV, JSON or NDJSON at any time, including after the agreement ends. Founding accounts cancel with no notice period. We would rather that be easy than have it be the reason you do not try.

—What we would say if you asked us straight

We have no customers yet, which means no testimonials, no case studies and no reviews anywhere. You would be taking a chance on something young, and the right way to read this page is as an argument rather than a track record.

AS2 is our other honest gap: the server is live with a certificate issued and it has not yet exchanged a message with a real retailer. If yours requires AS2, say so before you commit and we will tell you where it has got to rather than discover it with you.

If your retailer has given you a deadline inside a month and no appetite for risk, the vendor with a hundred live grocery suppliers is a reasonable choice and we will say so. Email hello@palletlabs.org and tell us the retailer and the date; we would rather point you somewhere else than sell you a year of something that does not fit.

—Still deciding?

Run your retailer's file through the validator first. It works in your browser, uploads nothing, and tells you whether we can read what they send before you give us an email address. Then tell us the retailer and the deadline.